.svg)
The stock market took a significant hit after the release of the September 2024 jobs report. While the U.S. economy added 142,000 jobs in August, falling short of the expected 165,000, the unemployment rate decreased to 4.2%, raising concerns among investors about the Federal Reserve’s upcoming rate cut decision. Revisions for prior months also showed weaker job growth, which shifted market expectations for the Fed's next move. Initially, traders anticipated a 50-basis-point rate cut, but odds later favored a smaller quarter-point cut, leaving investors uncertain about the central bank’s future course.
Why the Market Reacted Negatively
The mixed signals from the labor market data created confusion. While fewer jobs were added, the unemployment rate fell, suggesting the labor market is not cooling as much as expected. This complicates the Federal Reserve’s decision-making as it aims to balance the need for rate cuts with the risk of inflation re-accelerating. Bond yields initially surged, reflecting concerns that higher rates might persist longer than expected, leading to a sell-off in equities, particularly in tech stocks that are more sensitive to rate hikes.
Fed Governor Christopher Waller and New York Fed President John Williams both indicated a cautious approach to rate cuts, with Waller leaving open the possibility of a larger cut only if further data show a more dramatic economic slowdown. Traders reacted to this uncertainty by pulling back from riskier assets, contributing to a volatile week for the stock market.
Historical Comparisons: When Jobs Data Confused Markets
The market’s reaction to the September 2024 jobs report is reminiscent of other periods of Fed uncertainty. For instance, in June 2022, the S&P 500 and Nasdaq had similarly sharp drops after job reports showed strong labor market data, raising fears that the Fed would continue its aggressive rate hikes. Similarly, in December 2018, markets reacted poorly when a strong jobs report, combined with Fed tightening, sparked fears of a potential recession. In both cases, markets faced volatility as traders struggled to predict the Fed’s moves amid conflicting economic signals.
Technical Analysis: Breakdown of the Major Indexes
- Nasdaq Composite: Tech stocks led the decline, with the Nasdaq falling over 2.5%—its worst week since June 2022. The index broke through key support levels, suggesting potential further downside. A failure to hold above 13,000 could trigger additional selling pressure, particularly if bond yields continue to rise.
- S&P 500: The broader index dropped 1.7%, breaking below its 50-day moving average. This suggests that bearish sentiment may persist, with support around 4,200. Investors will watch this level closely, as further selling could push the index down to its next support zone.
- Dow Jones Industrial Average: The Dow dropped by around 1%, closing near its 200-day moving average. Historically, this level provides strong support, but if breached, it could signal a more significant correction.
What to Watch Going Forward
Markets are now in a wait-and-see mode ahead of the Federal Reserve’s September 17-18 meeting, where officials will decide on the size of the rate cut. Investors will closely monitor any additional labor market data, wage growth figures, and inflation reports in the days leading up to the meeting. Another critical factor will be the Fed’s long-term projections for rate cuts, which could help clarify the central bank’s approach to managing inflation versus economic growth.
Conclusion
The September jobs report sent mixed signals to the markets, leading to sharp declines across major indexes. With the labor market still showing resilience and uncertainty over the Fed’s next move, the market is bracing for continued volatility. Historically, similar scenarios have led to extended periods of market correction, but much will depend on how the Federal Reserve responds at its upcoming meeting. Investors should remain cautious and watch key technical levels as the market adjusts to new economic data.
Continued Reading:
The fed and the market moving effects they have are a fascinating subject. We recommend checking out some of these books (click the titles to go to their Amazon link):
This book explores how economic events are often driven by viral narratives and the stories we tell about financial markets, inflation, and recessions. Shiller, a Nobel Prize-winning economist, connects financial crises to the power of storytelling in economics.
This book provides insights into how the Federal Reserve, led by Jay Powell, navigated the economic challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic and the pressures of balancing monetary policy during an unprecedented global crisis.
This book examines historical economic crashes and the lessons they provide for preventing future financial crises. It offers a comprehensive look at major financial meltdowns, including the 2008 financial crisis.
This book explores seven major economic crises that have influenced globalization, discussing how each crisis led to different outcomes and what lessons can be drawn to understand future risks and opportunities in the global economy.
This book discusses how the Federal Reserve’s policies of quantitative easing have contributed to financial instability and worsened income inequality, offering a critical analysis of monetary policy and its long-term consequences.
